Tim Atkin MW · South Africa 2025

The best of
the Cape, 2025.

Tim Atkin tasted just under 2,000 South African wines this year. These are the ones that scored 95 points or better, plus everything he handed an award to.

Questions

Worth a minute before you start.

How do I ask for a wine?

Tap Add to request on any wine, as many as you like. Then Review and send at the bottom of the screen, fill in your name and a number, and send it on WhatsApp or by email. Nothing is charged from this page.

Is this an order?

No. It is a request. We come back to you on what we can get and what it costs, and then you decide. Nothing is bought and nothing is held by sending it.

What does the score mean?

Tim Atkin MW tastes just under 2,000 South African wines a year and marks them out of 100. Everything on this page scored 95 or better, or won one of his awards. The scores and the awards are his, quoted with attribution; the line under each wine is ours.

Can you get all of them?

Not always, and we would rather say so here than guess. Several are small allocations that go to whoever asks first. We have already left out the wines nobody can buy (the Cape Winemakers Guild auction lots), so everything on this page is worth asking about. Finding out for certain is exactly what we come back to you on.

Where do I collect, and do you deliver?

Collection is free at all three of our stores:

George · 80 York Street
Hartenbos · Shop 2, New Mere Group Building, 34 Kaap de Goede Hoop Avenue
Mossel Bay · Shop 28, Bayview Shopping Centre, Da Nova

We courier nationwide too. The courier and what it costs go into the quote we come back with, so there is nothing to work out here.

How long is this list good for?

The scores come from Tim Atkin’s 2025 report and stand for the year. Availability moves week to week, which is why we confirm what we can get before anything is charged.

Can I add to my request after sending it?

Yes. Add the wines and send it again from the same device. It keeps the same request code and the new list replaces the old, so please do not start a fresh one.

The full list, A–Z

All 213 wines, alphabetical by producer. Filter it, or search a name.

The podium · 2025

Tim’s awards for the year: the people as well as the wines.

The people

Tim’s awards to the makers, not the bottles.
Winemaker
Donovan Rall of Rall Wines
Young Winemaker
Stuart Botha of Tokara
Rising Star
Megan van der Merwe of Beau Constantia
Viticulturist
Danie Carinus of Bluegum Grove
Producers' Cellar
Riebeek Valley Wine Company
Winemaking Legend
Dr Paul Clüver
Best Cellar Door Experience
Gabriëlskloof

Wines of the year

The best of each colour and style.
White
Alheit Vineyards Magnetic North
100Exceptional
Alheit Vineyards
Magnetic North
2024 · Citrusdal Mountain
Red
Porseleinberg Syrah
100Exceptional
Porseleinberg
Syrah
2023 · Swartland
Rosé
Doolhof XCLUSIV Rosé
94Excellent
Doolhof
XCLUSIV Rosé
2025 · Limietberg
Sparkling
Graham Beck Cuvée Clive CC
97Superb
Graham Beck
Cuvée Clive CC
2019 · Western Cape
Sweet
Boekenhoutskloof Noble Late Harvest
98Exceptional
Boekenhoutskloof
Noble Late Harvest
2022 · Franschhoek
Fortified
97Superb
Boplaas
Colheita 20-Year-Old Cape Tawny
2005 · Calitzdorp

The discoveries

Wines Tim rates as the finds of the year.
Red
Beeslaar The Sacrament
97Superb
Beeslaar
The Sacrament
2022 · Stellenbosch
White
Sadie Family Twiswind
95Excellent
Sadie Family
Twiswind
2024 · Swartland
Rosé
93Excellent
Lost Boy
Latigo
2024 · Cape Agulhas
Fortified
Saldanha Oloroso No. 3
94Excellent
Saldanha
Oloroso No. 3
NV · Swartland
Sparkling
Boschendal Mountain Rose Pinot Noir Rosé CC
93Excellent
Boschendal
Mountain Rose Pinot Noir Rosé CC
2020 · Coastal

Best value

What he thinks punches above its price.
White
Windmeul Chenin Blanc OVP Reserve
92Excellent
Windmeul
Chenin Blanc OVP Reserve
2023 · Paarl
Red
91Excellent
Kloovenburg
Village Red
2024 · Swartland
Rosé
Le Sueur Grenache Rosé
91Excellent
Le Sueur
Grenache Rosé
2024 · Klein Karoo
Sparkling
Rebel Rebel Cinsault Méthode Ancestrale
90Excellent
Rebel Rebel
Cinsault Méthode Ancestrale
2024 · Bottelary Hills
Sweet
Van Loveren VRL Special Late Harvest Gewürztraminer
90Excellent
Van Loveren
VRL Special Late Harvest Gewürztraminer
2024 · Robertson
Fortified
KWV Classic Collection Cape Tawny
93Excellent
KWV
Classic Collection Cape Tawny
NV · Western Cape
Show the hall of fame: every winner since 2015

Winemakers of the Year

2015Eben Sadie
2016Abrie Beeslaar
2017Chris and Andrea Mullineux
2018Chris Alheit
2019Eben Sadie and Paul Jordaan
2020Gottfried Mocke
2021Peter-Allan Finlayson
2022Duncan Savage
2023Bruwer Raats
2024Callie Louw
2025Donovan Rall

Young Winemakers of the Year

2015Morné Vrey
2016Matt Day
2017Mark Le Roux
2018Lukas van Loggerenberg
2019Bernhard Bredell
2020David and Nadia Sadie
2021Elizma Visser
2022Charla Bosman
2023Marelise Niemann
2024Stephanie Wiid
2025Stuart Botha

Winemaking Legend

2017Neil Ellis
2018Jan Boland Coetzee
2019Gyles Webb
2020Peter Finlayson
2021Charles Back
2022Kevin Arnold
2023Etienne Le Riche
2024Günter Brözel
2025Dr Paul Clüver

Grower/Viticulturist of the Year

2018Basie van Lill
2019James Downes
2020Johan Reyneke
2021Marco Ventrella
2022Sheldon van Wyk
2023Willie Mostert
2024Bosman Family Vineyards
2025Danie Carinus

Producers' Cellar of the Year

2018Klawer Wine Cellars
2019Windmeul Kelder
2020Riebeek Valley Wine Company
2021Koelenhof Winery
2022Darling Cellars
2023Daschbosch
2024Perdeberg Wines
2025Riebeek Valley Wine Company

Best Cellar Door Experience

2019Creation
2020Delaire Graff
2021Waterford
2022Benguela Cove
2023Blaauwklippen Vineyards
2024Ernie Els Wines
2025Gabriëlksloof

Single estates

The houses that showed best this year, and what each of them put on the table.

Porseleinberg

First Growth · Swartland · 1 wines
Porseleinberg Syrah
100Exceptional
Syrah
2023

Mullineux

First Growth · Swartland · 7 wines
Mullineux Granite Eikelaan Chenin Blanc
97Superb
Granite Eikelaan Chenin Blanc
2024
R850
Mullineux Olerasay Straw Wine #5
97Superb
Olerasay Straw Wine #5
NV
Mullineux Roundstone Red
97Superb
Roundstone Red
2023
Mullineux Schist Roundstone Syrah
97Superb
Schist Roundstone Syrah
2023
R1,490
Mullineux Iron Rondomskrik Chenin Blanc
96Outstanding
Iron Rondomskrik Chenin Blanc
2024
R850
Mullineux Roundstone White
96Outstanding
Roundstone White
2024
Mullineux Straw Wine
96Outstanding
Straw Wine
2024
R760

Sadie Family

First Growth · Citrusdal Mountain, Stellenbosch, Swartland · 13 wines
Sadie Family Skerpioen
99Exceptional
Skerpioen
2024
Sadie Family Columella
98Exceptional
Columella
2023
Sadie Family Mev Kirsten
98Exceptional
Mev Kirsten
2024
Sadie Family Palladius
98Exceptional
Palladius
2023
Sadie Family 'T Voetpad
97Superb
'T Voetpad
2024
Sadie Family Rotsbank
97Superb
Rotsbank
2024
Sadie Family Skurfberg
97Superb
Skurfberg
2024
Sadie Family Pofadder
96Outstanding
Pofadder
2024
Sadie Family Soldaat
96Outstanding
Soldaat
2024
Sadie Family Kokerboom
95Excellent
Kokerboom
2024
Sadie Family Sonvang
95Excellent
Sonvang
2024
Sadie Family Treinspoor
95Excellent
Treinspoor
2024
Sadie Family Twiswind
95Excellent
Twiswind
2024

Alheit Vineyards

First Growth · Citrusdal Mountain, Franschhoek, Stellenbosch · 6 wines
Alheit Vineyards Magnetic North
100Exceptional
Magnetic North
2024
Alheit Vineyards Huilkrans
98Exceptional
Huilkrans
2024
Alheit Vineyards Nautical Dawn
98Exceptional
Nautical Dawn
2024
Alheit Vineyards Fire by Night
97Superb
Fire by Night
2024
Alheit Vineyards Cartology
96Outstanding
Cartology
2024
Alheit Vineyards Monument Semillon
96Outstanding
Monument Semillon
2024

Kershaw

First Growth · Elgin, Lower Duivenhoks River · 7 wines
Kershaw Chardonnay Deconstructed Lake District Bokkeveld Shale CY96
97Superb
Chardonnay Deconstructed Lake District Bokkeveld Shale CY96
2023
Kershaw Chardonnay Deconstructed Kogelberg Sandstone CY76
96Outstanding
Chardonnay Deconstructed Kogelberg Sandstone CY76
2023
Kershaw Pinot Noir Deconstructed Valley Ridge Gravel Over Clay PN777
96Outstanding
Pinot Noir Deconstructed Valley Ridge Gravel Over Clay PN777
2023
Kershaw Syrah Deconstructed Lake District Cartref SH9c
96Outstanding
Syrah Deconstructed Lake District Cartref SH9c
2022
Kershaw GPS Chardonnay Lower Duivenhoks River Chardonnay
95Excellent
GPS Chardonnay Lower Duivenhoks River Chardonnay
2023
Kershaw Pinot Noir Deconstructed Kogelberg Sandstone PN115
95Excellent
Pinot Noir Deconstructed Kogelberg Sandstone PN115
2023
Kershaw Syrah Deconstructed Lake District Cartref SH22
95Excellent
Syrah Deconstructed Lake District Cartref SH22
2022

Savage

First Growth · Cape Town, Darling, Piekenierskloof · 5 wines
Savage White
97Superb
White
2024
Savage Follow The Line
96Outstanding
Follow The Line
2024
Savage Girl Next Door
96Outstanding
Girl Next Door
2024
Savage Red
96Outstanding
Red
2023
Savage Thief in the Night
96Outstanding
Thief in the Night
2024

Boekenhoutskloof

First Growth · Franschhoek, Swartland · 4 wines
Boekenhoutskloof Noble Late Harvest
98Exceptional
Noble Late Harvest
2022
Boekenhoutskloof Semillon
96Outstanding
Semillon
2023
Boekenhoutskloof Syrah
96Outstanding
Syrah
2023
Boekenhoutskloof Cabernet Sauvignon
95Excellent
Cabernet Sauvignon
2023

Crystallum

First Growth · Elandskloof, Hemel-en-Aarde Ridge, Overberg · 4 wines
Crystallum Clay Shales Chardonnay
96Outstanding
Clay Shales Chardonnay
2024
Crystallum Cuvée Cinéma Pinot Noir
96Outstanding
Cuvée Cinéma Pinot Noir
2024
Crystallum Mabalel Pinot Noir
96Outstanding
Mabalel Pinot Noir
2024
Crystallum Litigo Pinot Noir
95Excellent
Litigo Pinot Noir
2024

Damascene

First Growth · Ceres Plateau, Franschhoek, Stellenbosch · 4 wines
Damascene Syrah
98Exceptional
Syrah
2023
Damascene Syrah
97Superb
Syrah
2023
Damascene Syrah
96Outstanding
Syrah
2023
Damascene Semillon
95Excellent
Semillon
2023

David & Nadia

First Growth · Swartland · 4 wines
David & Nadia Plat'bos OVP Chenin Blanc
97Superb
Plat'bos OVP Chenin Blanc
2024
David & Nadia Skaliekop OVP Chenin Blanc
97Superb
Skaliekop OVP Chenin Blanc
2024
David & Nadia Hoë-Steen OVP Chenin Blanc
96Outstanding
Hoë-Steen OVP Chenin Blanc
2024
96Outstanding
Langland OVP Chenin Blanc
2024

Graham Beck

Second Growth · Robertson, Western Cape · 4 wines
Graham Beck Cuvée Clive CC
97Superb
Cuvée Clive CC
2019
96Outstanding
Artisan Collection Single Vineyard Chardonnay
2020
Graham Beck Blanc de Blancs CC Magnum
96Outstanding
Blanc de Blancs CC Magnum
2019
Graham Beck Cuvée Clive X CC
96Outstanding
Cuvée Clive X CC
2015

Rall

First Growth · Coastal, Swartland · 4 wines
Rall Ava Syrah
97Superb
Ava Syrah
2024
Rall Noa OVP Chenin Blanc
96Outstanding
Noa OVP Chenin Blanc
2024
95Excellent
Ava Chenin Blanc
2024
Rall White
95Excellent
White
2024
0 wines on your request A request is not an order. We come back to you on price and availability.